Empty corridor hospital
In July 2023, the nation was shaken by a heartbreaking story out of Georgia: a newborn baby was decapitated during delivery. The parents had waited nine months for a healthy child. Instead, they left the hospital with devastation, unanswered questions, and the unthinkable truth that their child had died due to trauma sustained at birth.
What Happened in Georgia
The child died during delivery after a well-known obstetric complication called shoulder dystocia, where the baby’s shoulders become stuck behind the mother’s pelvis after the head is delivered. In this case, the physician attempted to resolve the dystocia by pulling too forcefully at a time when a cesarean section should have been performed. That excessive pulling, combined with delayed surgical intervention, resulted in the baby's neck being broken.
The Medical Examiner's office later ruled the baby's death a homicide caused by a fracture of cervical vertebrae and spinal cord during delivery. The case against the hospital and the delivering doctor regarding the delivery remains pending.
**Recent Update**
Separately, the parents hired Dr. Jackson Gates to perform a private autopsy, but he allegedly posted graphic videos of the decapitated baby on Instagram without their consent. The parents sued Dr. Gates for invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of emotional distress, and fraud. A jury awarded them $2.25 million against Dr. Gates and his business for posting the videos.
Why This Matters for Texans
This case is horrifying. But in Texas, it would be even more tragic—for one reason:
Under Texas law, healthcare providers would be completely immune from liability. No accountability. No fair compensation. No justice.
In Texas, No Breath Means No Case
Under current Texas law, for parents to bring a wrongful death claim, the baby must be born alive. Even if the baby dies seconds later, they are considered a person under the law. But if the baby dies during labor, even from egregious medical negligence, they are not afforded the same legal status.
The result? If a baby dies moments before taking a breath, the parents cannot sue for wrongful death. They cannot recover funeral expenses, medical bills, emotional damages, or hold anyone accountable in court. Their child does not legally “exist” in the eyes of the law.
This should shock the conscious of every Texan. No one should be okay with this.
The Deep Hypocrisy in Texas Law
There is a cruel irony in a state that so aggressively purports to be “pro-life,” but offers zero recourse to heartbroken families of deeply wanted pregnancies that do not result in live birth due purely to medical negligence.
In 2003, the Texas Legislature amended the state’s Wrongful Death Act to allow claims for the death of an unborn child, but with one glaring exception: medical malpractice. Inexplicably, Texas law excludes families from bringing wrongful death claims against negligent healthcare providers unless the baby takes at least one breath outside the womb.
This exception was a direct concession to the healthcare industry and continues to shield negligent providers from accountability, even in the most egregious cases.
The state of Texas boasts some of the country’s most punitive anti-abortion laws. At the same time, Texas healthcare providers are completely immune from liability unless a healthy, viable baby is delivered. Under current Texas law, a baby who dies in utero because of a doctor’s preventable mistake — even in horrific circumstances or gross negligence — is not considered a wrongful death. The parents cannot seek justice. The negligent party cannot be held responsible. That’s not just unjust, it’s inhumane.
This legal loophole disregards the deep and devastating impact of losing a child in the final days of pregnancy. A mother who has carried her baby to term, chosen a name, decorated the nursery, and prepared for a lifetime of love should not be told her child “doesn’t count” simply because the tragedy occurred before the baby took a breath, and because the harm came at the hands of a physician. This cruel legal hypocrisy inflicts tragedy on all circumstances of pregnancy, and the women and families of Texas deserve better.
Families Deserve Better. TEXAS LAW MUST CHANGE.
Families who lose their unborn children due to medical malpractice deserve the same access to justice as any other grieving parent. The value of that life and the depth of that loss should not depend on how the child died, or who caused it.
It’s time for Texas to stop protecting negligent healthcare providers at the expense of families. It’s time to close this cruel loophole in our wrongful death laws.
A Call for Change
The heartbreaking case out of Georgia is more than just a tragic story, it’s a powerful reminder of what’s at stake when medical systems fail and the law falls short. For Texans, it should prompt serious reflection on whether our own laws truly serve the needs of patients and grieving families.
It’s time for Texas to reevaluate outdated legal protections that favor powerful healthcare interests over the rights of everyday people. Patients deserve a legal system that values truth, accountability, and justice.
We believe Texas can do better. The law should reflect the dignity of every life, and ensure families have a voice when medical negligence turns lives upside down.
Now is the time for meaningful reform.